Make sure everything in your basket ties specifically to an event, memory, or meal from the day you are attempting to re-create. Take the time to explain to your date why each item in your basket has a special meaning to you, and make sure that the reason it has meaning to you is because it reminds you of something wonderful about your date.
For couples who are celebrating their first Valentine’s Day together and have not been a couple for too long, you might try a more playful theme…
Try something reminiscent of those cheesy high school prom or college formal themes like “A Night in Vegas” or “A Night at the Oscars.” Depending on how you feel about your relationship, you might try something a little more romantic like “The Day We Met” or “Things That Make Me Think of You.” Again, it’s important to take the time to explain each element so that your date knows you planned it out just for them. The fact that you took the time to think of each detail – no matter how “cheesy” it might seem – means a lot.
What do I mean by that? Well, maybe you’re a klutz in the kitchen so you buy a bag of fast food and put it in a picnic basket because it’s the best you can do. Or maybe you’re a mechanic and all you’ve got around to use as a “picnic basket” is a tool box you empty out. Whatever it is that you do, there’s something unmistakably “you” about the whole experience that is endearing, and it makes for a memorable evening.
Maybe it’s flowers, maybe it’s an engagement ring, or maybe it’s simply a note that says, “My dear, when we get home, you’ll see I finally fixed that leaky faucet you’ve been asking me to fix for weeks. I’m sorry I didn’t get to it sooner.” Put in an element of the unexpected that shows you care.
Now, if you’re not confident in your ability to make crème brulee, or if that’s just not your style, do something as simple as tossing a salad in-person. (NOTE: If you’re serving a green salad, you need to toss it when you get there anyway, or you’ll have a wilted, soggy salad). Besides showcasing your cooking talent, there’s something about the act of cooking in front of your date that says, “I love you.” Perhaps it’s because you’re actively serving your date and accommodating his or her needs.
If nothing else, your date will treasure the note and the memory of the picnic you made for years to come.
Keep in mind that a lot of food items should only be in the “danger zone” (40⁰F – 140⁰F) for no more than 4 hours. For example, if you’re going to pack sushi (of the raw fish variety), find a way to pack it on ice, even if that means that you can’t use an actual picnic basket. For food safety reasons, I wouldn’t recommend hot foods because it’s hard to keep them hot enough for an extended period of time. If you do decide to pack a hot meal, make sure you have a way to keep it above 140⁰F.
So if my husband and I follow your tips, are we guaranteed to win your competition on Valentine’s Day?